top of page

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  1. What is the current situation regarding the First Miami Presbyterian Church?

    • The First Miami Presbyterian Church (FMPC) symbolizes an integral part of Miami's history and architectural heritage. 

    • There is a significant development proposal to demolish a portion of the First Miami Presbyterian Church, which was historically classified until a recent declassification. 

    • In its place, an 80-story high-rise with an estimate of 640 residential units will rise, some 15-20 feet away from the hallowed church walls.

    • Together, these aspects jeopardize the preservation of a significant cultural asset that has shaped our community.

  2. What are the potential consequences of this development on the community?

    • The sweeping changes could jeopardize not only our local history and environment but also diminish the quality of life for residents by increasing traffic, pollution, and reducing open and green spaces, which are critical for community well-being.

  3. What impact will this development have on traffic and infrastructure? 

    • The development is projected to introduce over 900 additional vehicles into the neighborhood, exacerbating existing traffic congestion and pollution. This will further strain an already overloaded infrastructure and degrade the quality of life for residents

  4. How does this development affect Brickell's environmental challenges?

    • Brickell has less than 10% of its land capable of absorbing water runoff. Thus, losing vital green space will heighten flooding risks and amplify ongoing environmental challenges in the area.

    • The roots of the ancient tree canopy of Brickell Park are spread over and underground. A massive high rise will endanger the ancient deep-rooted trees.

  5. What is the history of the First Miami Presbyterian Church?

    • The First Miami Presbyterian Church houses Miami’s oldest congregation, organized in April 1896. The new congregation first worshiped in a tent at what is now the corner of North Miami Avenue and SE 2nd Street.Henry M. Flagler donated the lots and provided the funding for the construction of a permanent church building in 1900. The original church was located at the corner of East Flagler Street and SE 3rd Avenue and served the congregation until the 1940s.

    • The new and present church building was completed in 1949 and is the only remaining structure associated with this important early congregation. The present church building houses what is known as the Flagler Memorial Chapel, which contains salvaged portions of the original church building from 1900. It is eligible for designation as it exemplifies the historical, cultural, political, economic, or social trends of the community.

    • In 1953, an educational wing was added behind the original church. Subsequent expansions included a second floor above the educational wing and a two-story U-shaped addition, completed between 1962 and 1963, all of which maintain the same architectural style and materials as the original structure.

    • The church represents an exceptional example of late Mediterranean Revival styling in Miami, featuring elements of the Romanesque mode. While this architectural style was popular throughout the 1920s and 1930s in South Florida, the church’s construction in 1949 is a rare find at mid-century.

  6. When was First Miami Presbyterian Church granted historical status?

    • The historic building was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1989 and designated by the City of Miami in 2003 (21 years ago).

    • The nomination form for the National Register of Historic Places, dated 1988, lists the significance of multiple historic resources, including the First Presbyterian Church.

    • The visual composition of the church is architecturally noteworthy for its stylistic features and use of local materials.

  7. What are the most recent legal updates?

    • First Miami Presbyterian Church (FMPC) applied to the Historical and Environmental Preservation Board (HEPB) to declassify its historical status, which was declined on July 2, 2024.  

    • FMPC then filed a second application to declassify a significant portion of the Church’s historical infrastructure which houses an educational facility.  

    • During the second hearing, neighboring Brickell residents from Icon Brickell 2 requested intervenor status, but their request was denied (3 votes for, 5 against).  

    • Intervenor status allows for legal participation in all proceedings and in this case be permitted to make a presentation, call and examine witnesses, conduct cross-examination of witnesses, rebut evidence, and make final arguments before the HEPB in accordance with the Code. However, the HEPB denied Icon Brickell 2’s request to intervene and thus violated the Code. This error requires the City Commission to reverse the Resolution.

    • The HEPB approved FMPC's request to declassify  the rear portion of the church, despite its historic designation from 2003.  

    • Denying residents the right to intervene violates the City of Miami Code of Ordinances. 

    • On April 10, the City Commission heard the appeal, but denied it. 

  8. What do residents want if historical classification is granted?

    • Stronger safeguards for historic sites, green spaces, open spaces, schools, and landmarks that contribute to Brickell's cultural and historical identity. This effort aims to preserve the area's unique character for future generations.

    • Independent assessments for any projects that could threaten the area's heritage or environment. These evaluations by unbiased experts would provide transparent insights into the potential impacts of proposed developments, helping to mitigate adverse effects.

    • To be involved in decisions that shape their neighborhoods, ensuring their needs and values are represented. This participation fosters a sense of ownership and responsibility for their community's evolution.

  9. Is Brickell Stronger Together against all development?

    • No. Residents support the church's right to monetize properties that do not compromise Miami's historical legacy. They understand the need for reasonable financial sustainability to maintain the church’s operations. 

    • The community envisions developments around the church that create accessible, enjoyable spaces prioritizing historical preservation, environmental sustainability, and safety. This approach would enhance Brickell’s appeal as a vibrant, inclusive neighborhood while respecting the church’s heritage.

    • We understand the need for responsible development that balances community growth with sustainability, ensuring that the negative consequences on Brickell's future are carefully considered.

  10.  How can I get involved with Brickell Stronger Together?

    • Residents can get involved by participating in discussions, joining events organized by BST, and contributing their ideas and concerns.

    • By signing up for our newsletter to stay informed with any updates and call to actions. 

bottom of page